@cindyy: I guess you can see from the variety of answers that there is no easy answer. If we just look at your question "Which is cheaper?", then I think the answer is either HEB or Super Walmart. However, when you factor in convenience, availability of favorite brands, etc, etc, people choose something else. My wife hits the Super Walmart about once a month for canned goods, frozen foods, etc. Then she will go to either Krogers or Randalls for meats, fresh vegetables, etc. depending on the weekly sales papers. 4951