Me..i would probably throw away the five crac ked ones then add the half dozen to the other 3 dozen egg cartons I have in the fridge because when I was at the store for brownie ingredients I couldn't remember if I had eggs or not at the house so I just bought more..then on trash day I throw out a couple dozen eggs and start over the next week. That's just me. Your soup looks good.i wouldn't eat it..but it looks good 4951