Close
Agape Garage Doors, LLC

Am I the only one having a hard time believing that the action o

Am I the only one having a hard time believing that the action o
Go to top of page
1234
FASTLANE: This "Fastlane" discussion may cover sensitive, inflammatory, or controversial topics. See Fastlane guidelines »
Replies:
Message Menu
CartmanUK35 11.3 yrs
~ 4 hrs ago    
#msg6057066CartmanUK35 : Coercion is the practice of forcing a person to act against their free will through threats, intimidation, pressure, or physical force. Not sure where the coercion is. You are free to choose. Is it coercion to notify someone of the benefits or consequences of their choices and then allowing them to make an informed decision?
it's coercion if you create the circumstances of their needing to choose and make the desirable outcome contingent on following you, your framing of the situation is disingenuous at best. It is also coercion to make the good outcome conditional, which is what is happening here, if you are the person placing that condition and requiring the following then painting it as a simple free will exercise is beyond dishonest.
 
TxManiac :
Message Menu
TxManiac 9.6 yrs
~ 4 hrs ago    
CartmanUK35 :
I'm still not seeing coercion. If you do not wish to participate, you are free to disregard any information. How is that not freewill? You get to choose. Advising someone of their options and potential outcomes hardly qualifies as coercion. Is it coercion when doctor advises you on a treatment and advises you of the consequences of your choice to follow or not their advice? It seems like there is an underlying motivation to your argument.
Message Menu
CartmanUK35 11.3 yrs
~ 3 hrs, 23 mins ago    
#msg6057083CartmanUK35 : I'm still not seeing coercion. If you do not wish to participate, you are free to disregard any information. How is that not freewill? You get to choose. Advising someone of their options and potential outcomes hardly qualifies as coercion. Is it coercion when doctor advises you on a treatment and advises you of the consequences of your choice to follow or not their advice? It seems like there is an underlying motivation to your argument.
 
TxManiac : You're still conflating free will with freedom from coercion. Nobody is suggesting that someone loses the ability to refuse. The argument is that the existence of a choice doesn't automatically make the circumstances surrounding that choice non-coercive.
 
Your doctor analogy actually demonstrates the distinction. A doctor didn't create your illness, establish the biological rules governing it, or deliberately design the consequences of refusing treatment. They're advising you on how to deal with circumstances they didn't create and generally cannot control.
 
God, however, is supposedly omnipotent and the creator of everything. That means we're discussing an entity that created the circumstances, established the rules, determined the consequences and controls the means of escaping those consequences.
 
You can't reasonably separate the offer from the circumstances that make the offer necessary when the same entity is responsible for both.
 
And as for your suggestion that there's an underlying motivation to my argument, that doesn't address any of the points being made. Whether you agree with the theological premise or not, the philosophical question remains: does having the ability to refuse an ultimatum make it any less coercive?
 
Free will and coercion are not mutually exclusive concepts.
Message Menu
TxManiac 9.6 yrs
~ 2 hrs, 29 mins ago    
CartmanUK35 :
If you follow the Bible, it expressly says that God did not create the circumstances. The circumstances were created by man. If that's not an acceptable premise, then why not just view it as a fairytale and move on?
CartmanUK35 reacted
Message Menu
buffaloglenn Online 14.4 yrs
~ 1 hr, 34 mins ago    
#msg6055145If you've ever experienced working somewhere with an IT department.....totally believable.
 
Tigrlily : That's what I was going to say - I've never worked directly in IT but was on the user end of some software projects, and saw firsthand, that a lot of stuff / fixes happen behind the scenes without the world knowing about it and getting their knickers in a twist.
Message Menu
CartmanUK35 11.3 yrs
~ 1 hr, 13 mins ago    
#msg6057135CartmanUK35 : If you follow the Bible, it expressly says that God did not create the circumstances. The circumstances were created by man. If that's not an acceptable premise, then why not just view it as a fairytale and move on?
 
TxManiac : That is a cop out, it's not simply unacceptable, it doesn't hold up under basic scrutiny, he created everything, he created everyone aware of what they would do and what actions they would take and then imposes requirements on them, he is absolutely responsible for the circumstances if he created the ability for them to arise and had foreknowledge they would, and while it IS a fairytale, so long as we are subject to people attempting to shape our lives around said fairytale I won't simply "move on".
Message Menu
TxManiac 9.6 yrs
~ 56 mins ago    
CartmanUK35 :
I can tell you are a little defensive. I enjoy a good debate but it doesn't seem like that is of interest right now. I will say that just because He gave them the option of choice does not men He is responsible that they chose poorly. I am not sure who is "trying to shape your life", but that's not the way Christianity is supposed to work. We simply share what we believe and if there is no interest, move on. I'm not trying to force my beliefs on anyone. It's obvious, there is no interest, so I will move on. I hope you find whatever gives you happiness.
Post a comment »

FASTLANE: This "Fastlane" discussion may cover sensitive, inflammatory, or controversial topics. See Fastlane guidelines »
« Back to Chat
Views: 1,351
# Replies: 52