So gun confiscation is now on the table? Are they going to go in
So gun confiscation is now on the table? Are they going to go in
Joined:
X days ago
# Posts:
X,XXX
Contributor Points:
X
Replies:
That is a straw man argument. I own a gun, I think owning a gun is good thing, however the fact of it is we don't do a good job at actually regulating who gets to have guns. I was able to go into a store and walk out with a gun the same day. In Texas you can open and conceal carry without a license, meaning that even if you don't have the proper training you can carry in public. As a society we should try to mitigate deaths as much as we can. Additionally it is horrible that gun violence is the leading cause of death of children and teens in the US, do we not owe children a semblance of safety?
You are correct mass shooting do not make up the mass majority of gun fatalities but you know what does suicides. Which goes back to root cause for mass shooting and suicides which is mental health. The piece of legislature says that a person within the household or police officer can petition with a judge, which means they have provide proof, that you are danger to yourself or others to be able to confiscate your weapons. This proactive, this good.
#msg6053772sweetie : There's already laws on the books that prohibit felons from possessing firearms.
for those that would stand behind the argument that a law should not be passed, because criminals would ignore it - - please substitute guns for any other regulated item or action - and see how uninformed that argument is. at some points thoughts and prayers should give way to regulated preventative measures. the right wing has been playing the fear card way too long and folks are tiring of it. Johnie isn't coming home from school as susie, Hillary isn't dealing kids in a pizza parlor, Obama isn't planning a government overthrow from abandoned walmarts, one muslim senator (who was born in America, holds and MD and a PHD and was captian of high school football team) does not equate to a muslim takeover forcing our kids into Sharia law and our girls to wear burkas; the Clintons, Obamas and Bidens have moved on from politics - so find a new dead horse. Happy Saturday
rocket, sebastian2 and LemonEye + 2 more reacted And what would you propose for that legislation? The "straw man" argument you reference simply boils down to creating more laws regulating gun ownership would have no affect on people who don't follow laws. Most of the murders are being committed by lawless people all ready. If you were able to walk out the same day after purchase, you either have a carry license or were able to pass the background check. Not everyone gets to do that. As for children, roughly 1/4 of those deaths are gang related and another 30% are suicide. I'd love a way to prevent that without infringing on the rights of the majority. I've just never seen one that was able to do both. Parents of children who are able to get access to a gun should answer for that. If that access was due to carelessness, then they should bear the responsibility. The issue is not the gun, it's the mentality of the shooter. Treat the disease, not the symptom.
The straw man argument I was referring to was your position of banning cars. You are correct, laws will be broken, it doesn't mean we shouldn't create laws to prevent or deter. The solutions you stand behind is no solution. That way you get to keep your guns, when the law being presented wouldn't even affect you unless you are danger to yourself or others.
My bias is more based in the fact that once we allow the government to erode our rights as citizens, we will start down a path that we have no idea where it ends. If they can take away the 2nd amendment, the precedent is set. Why not the 1st? I do own guns and I have a license to carry. "Those who would give up essential Liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither Liberty nor safety" Benjamin Franklin
for those that would stand behind the argument that a law should not be passed, because criminals would ignore it - - please substitute guns for any other regulated item or action - and see how uninformed that argument is. at some points thoughts and prayers should give way to regulated preventative measures. the right wing has been playing the fear card way too long and folks are tiring of it. Johnie isn't coming home from school as susie, Hillary isn't dealing kids in a pizza parlor, Obama isn't planning a government overthrow from abandoned walmarts, one muslim senator (who was born in America, holds and MD and a PHD and was captian of high school football team) does not equate to a muslim takeover forcing our kids into Sharia law and our girls to wear burkas; the Clintons, Obamas and Bidens have moved on from politics - so find a new dead horse. Happy Saturday
#msg6054253TxManiac : The straw man argument I was referring to was your position of banning cars. You are correct, laws will be broken, it doesn't mean we shouldn't create laws to prevent or deter. The solutions you stand behind is no solution. That way you get to keep your guns, when the law being presented wouldn't even affect you unless you are danger to yourself or others.
#msg6054476and allow people to exercise their God given rights
Owning a gun is not a God-given right
#msg6054839TxManiac : Owning a gun is not a God-given right
I was speaking to the mental health issues. Gender dysphoria and the transformative drugs may contribute, not the number of mass shootings.
#msg6054938Sophos3 : I was speaking to the mental health issues. Gender dysphoria and the transformative drugs may contribute, not the number of mass shootings.
I'm aware what you meant and how you meant it. So, you have attributed a theory to 0.1% of the over all shootings using about 0 actual understanding of what you're talking about. Isn't math handy. Another fun little percentage is 80% to 81% of shootings happen because of personal mental crisis... someone snaps. A relationship is destroyed, they lose their job, financial collapse, basically their reality is shattered and they snap and decide to share their pain with the world. Ever consider that some of those folks in the meme you posted might have snapped because of being harassed, marginalized, demonized, and made miserable by folks like the one who maybe made the meme?
Views: 1,447
# Replies: 80


