So gun confiscation is now on the table? Are they going to go in
So gun confiscation is now on the table? Are they going to go in
Joined:
X days ago
# Posts:
X,XXX
Contributor Points:
X
Replies:
#msg6054014Sophos3 : All lives are important. YTD, 8728 people have been killed by gun violence. 60-62% were suicide (5237). That leaves 3491. Roughly half of those were involved in a "mass shooting". Outside of those 2 statistics, there are 1746 people who have dies due to gun violence. 16,750 people have dies in car accidents in the 1st half of 2026. That's double the number of total deaths and almost 10 times the number outside of the two groups mentioned. Shouldn't we be more focused on that?
Let me answer your question, but pose a question to you first. Do you know what a false equivalency is? Car deaths are normally tragic accidents involving something designed for transportation, whereas gun violence involves tools designed for lethal force used in deliberate acts of harm. Next, you're bolstering your false equivalency with a false dilemma. Believe it or not, society can focus on more than one crisis at a time. Cars are already among the most heavily regulated things on earth, requiring licensing, testing, registration, and insurance. So society already heavily focuses on traffic safety while remaining fully capable of addressing gun violence( and mental illness, for that matter) but it doesn't.
I am well aware of what a false equivalency is? It's like comparing a driving privilege to a constitutionally guaranteed right?
#msg6054020Sophos3 : Who defines that? More liberal websites define it differently than conservatives. For statistical tracking of mass murder/shootings, the FBI has traditionally looked at incidents involving 4 or more deaths in a single event (excluding the shooter). The Rockefeller Institute of Government: Defines it as an incident of targeted violence at a public or populated location with multiple victims (injuries or fatalities) within a 24-hour period. Gun Violence Archive defines a mass shooting as an incident in which 4 or more people are shot (injured or killed), not including the shooter, regardless of the circumstances.
Liberal websites. 🤣Debating how many bodies it takes to label something a tragedy doesn't alter the objective body count, nor does the disagreement over definitions erase the statistical reality of the violence itself. You can interpret it how you want but you're starting with basic confirmation bias and will see what you want to see and ignore the rest.
#msg6054026Sophos3 : I am well aware of what a false equivalency is? It's like comparing a driving privilege to a constitutionally guaranteed right?
Actually it is not... Shifting from physical design to legal status is just moving the goalposts. A constitutional right doesn't change the physical purpose of a weapon, and doesn't disprove how society regulates dangerous things.
My bias is more based in the fact that once we allow the government to erode our rights as citizens, we will start down a path that we have no idea where it ends. If they can take away the 2nd amendment, the precedent is set. Why not the 1st? I do own guns and I have a license to carry. "Those who would give up essential Liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither Liberty nor safety" Benjamin Franklin
#msg6054028TxManiac : Actually it is not... Shifting from physical design to legal status is just moving the goalposts. A constitutional right doesn't change the physical purpose of a weapon, and doesn't disprove how society regulates dangerous things.
#msg6054029Sophos3 : My bias is more based in the fact that once we allow the government to erode our rights as citizens, we will start down a path that we have no idea where it ends. If they can take away the 2nd amendment, the precedent is set. Why not the 1st? I do own guns and I have a license to carry. "Those who would give up essential Liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither Liberty nor safety" Benjamin Franklin
Have you ever been shot, shot someone (outside of military combat), or know someone who's been shot? Jesus, the slippery slope schtick... The idea that regulating guns will automatically destroy all our rights is just a paranoid fallacy. Just like we limit free speech to prevent defamation or yelling fire in a crowded theatre without losing the First Amendment, we can regulate firearms to protect public safety without eliminating the Second Amendment. Plus, Benjamin Franklin's famous quote is completely misunderstood here... he was actually criticizing a wealthy family for trying to bribe their way out of a tax meant for community defense. Franklin believed true freedom requires cooperation, and even later wrote that individual rights must bend to whatever is "necessary for the preservation of society."
#msg6054028TxManiac : Actually it is not... Shifting from physical design to legal status is just moving the goalposts. A constitutional right doesn't change the physical purpose of a weapon, and doesn't disprove how society regulates dangerous things.
I've never been shot and I have never shot another person. Not sure what Jesus has to do with it. A paranoid fantasy is a matter of opinion and not a fact. Defamation is not a limiting of free speech, it a legal consequence of abusing it. You can yell "Fire!" in a theater but you cannot avoid the potential consequences of it. Both examples are post action, not preventative. And while Franklin was addressing the situation as you correctly identified, it is an axiom that holds truth. Freedom and safety will always be at odds. The question remains, how much of one are you willing to sacrifice for the other.
#msg6054032Sophos3 : On this I strongly disagree. All of our laws are subject to the constitution, not equal to it. The whole intent for having a Supreme Court was to determine if laws were in agreement with our constitutional rights or not. Admittedly, they have gone awry from the original charter, but the constitution stands above the law, not adjacent or equal to it. That's the reason driving is a privilege while owning a gun is a right. I do not see any equivalency in the two.
One, Even the Supreme Court explicitly ruled that the Second Amendment is not absolute and can be regulated... if the ultimate authority on the Constitution says rights have limits to protect public safety.
#msg6054035Sophos3 : Actually, I have no issue with someone's rights being regulated or removed as long at there is a hearing and evidence is presented, a defense is mounted and judgement is rendered to the individual. It's a blanket restriction that I take issue with where a person has to prove innocence to keep their rights that according to the framers are granted by God.
Two, the Constitution doesn't say anything about God granting squadoo. Maybe your thinking of the Declaration of Independence. Now the words well regulated to appear and there is that. No one is coming to take away guns without a reason. This is the same **** people freaked out about with Jade Helm 15 military takeover panic, the hidden FEMA camps narrative, the UN globalist disarmament plot, the "false flag" mass shooting crisis actor theories, and the universal background checks are a Trojan horse for absolute federal gun confiscation.
#msg6054037Sophos3 : I've never been shot and I have never shot another person. Not sure what Jesus has to do with it. A paranoid fantasy is a matter of opinion and not a fact. Defamation is not a limiting of free speech, it a legal consequence of abusing it. You can yell "Fire!" in a theater but you cannot avoid the potential consequences of it. Both examples are post action, not preventative. And while Franklin was addressing the situation as you correctly identified, it is an axiom that holds truth. Freedom and safety will always be at odds. The question remains, how much of one are you willing to sacrifice for the other.
Jesus was used as an expletive to see how much you rely on AI to respond. As for the rest, I do know several people who've been shot. No one died but the damage from taking one in the shoulder even can be brutal. He was shot while playing basketball at a Kingwood elementary school. His range of motion on his arm is up and down and his hand basically works like a claw. Anyhow, no point arguing with a proxy for AI. Have a good evening. 😉
Two: I never said the constitution said our rights were granted by God. You are correct that was the Declaration of Independence. The Constitution was simply the enumeration of the rights referenced in the Declaration.
After that you kind of went all "tinfoil hat". We can go down the "well regulated" road, but ultimately it is clear it was intended to allow us to protect ourselves from a government that might disarm local populations or subvert state authority, making an explicit constitutional safeguard necessary.
I always enjoy a good debate and you have al my respect. I am sorry to hear about the incident you referenced. That is truly tragic and adds context to your arguments. We may not agree on everything but I appreciate the chance to exercise my brain cells. I do use AI to ensure that I am using facts rather than feelings, but the arguments are all me. Have a good night and I hope we cross paths again.
#msg6054044Sophos3 : One: I never said I thought the Supreme Court always gets it right. I merely suggested that their main focus was to ensure the constitutionality of legislative actions were consistent with the constitution. Two: I never said the constitution said our rights were granted by God. You are correct that was the Declaration of Independence. The Constitution was simply the enumeration of the rights referenced in the Declaration. After that you kind of went all "tinfoil hat". We can go down the "well regulated" road, but ultimately it is clear it was intended to allow us to protect ourselves from a government that might disarm local populations or subvert state authority, making an explicit constitutional safeguard necessary.
See what you replied, yeah... AI. It couldn't determine what some of the text was referring to because it didn't have the whole conversation to reference to gain context. Like this little sample. "keep their rights that according to the framers are granted by God."
Ok. Good day.
#msg6054048TxManiac : See what you replied, yeah... AI. It couldn't determine what some of the text was referring to because it didn't have the whole conversation to reference to gain context. Like this little sample. "keep their rights that according to the framers are granted by God." Ok. Good day.
Views: 1,485
# Replies: 80

