Close
Clayton Services

So gun confiscation is now on the table? Are they going to go in

So gun confiscation is now on the table? Are they going to go in
Go to top of page
123456Next PageLast Page
FASTLANE: This "Fastlane" discussion may cover sensitive, inflammatory, or controversial topics. See Fastlane guidelines »
Replies:
Message Menu
dingo2
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
sweetie :
" Under the proposal, family members, household members, and law enforcement officers could petition a court to restrict an individual's firearm rights if they believe the person poses an immediate danger because of alleged mental illness and access to firearms." this is actually incredibly proactive. What is the negative on this?
ExCTGuyInTX + 1 more reacted
Message Menu
dingo2
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
GiggleMugs :
"White males (excluding transgender and non-binary individuals) account for approximately 55.4% of mass shooters in the United States based on historical data from 1966 through May 2026", your villainization of a minority is reductive to the issue at hand.
"According to data compiled by the Gun Violence Archive and reported by organizations like GLAAD and Wikipedia, out of thousands of mass shootings in the United States between 2013 and late 2025, there have been 5 confirmed transgender or non-binary perpetrators."
ExCTGuyInTX and StGetoffmylawn1 + 1 more reacted
Message Menu
dingo2
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
GiggleMugs :
Additionally
"University of Maryland show that right-wing extremism (including white supremacy, far-right anti-government groups, and related subcultures) accounts for the large majority (roughly 75% to 84%) of ideologically motivated domestic terrorist homicides over recent decades."
ExCTGuyInTX and StGetoffmylawn1 reacted
Message Menu
GiggleMugs Top Forum Contributor4.1 yrs
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
dingo2 :
Did you look at the pictures and events? Percentage has to be much higher because of the years studied. 1966? Lol!
Message Menu
justanirishgirl Top Forum Contributor12.7 yrs
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
People can always get a gun somewhere. Don't think legislation will change this. It's silly to think bad people will follow the law.
Phillygirl and Sunnycl + 2 more reacted
Message Menu
mutton Online Top Forum Contributor12 yrs
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
#msg6053731dingo2 : Did you look at the pictures and events? Percentage has to be much higher because of the years studied. 1966? Lol!
 
GiggleMugs : Where is the source you have for yours?
Message Menu
dingo2
~ 3 days, 24 hrs ago    
GiggleMugs :
By your picture only 5 of those people are confirmed to be part of the trans community.
Message Menu
rocket 17.6 yrs
~ 3 days, 23 hrs ago    
#msg6053712rocket : But no legislation to take the guns away from the criminals
 
sweetie :
There's already laws on the books that prohibit felons from possessing firearms.
ExCTGuyInTX and Phillygirl reacted
Message Menu
Boonie 6.5 yrs
~ 3 days, 23 hrs ago    
#msg6053727GiggleMugs : "White males (excluding transgender and non-binary individuals) account for approximately 55.4% of mass shooters in the United States based on historical data from 1966 through May 2026", your villainization of a minority is reductive to the issue at hand. "According to data compiled by the Gun Violence Archive and reported by organizations like GLAAD and Wikipedia, out of thousands of mass shootings in the United States between 2013 and late 2025, there have been 5 confirmed transgender or non-binary perpetrators."
 
dingo2 : Roughly 1800 killed in mass shootings last 30-40 years. Over a million killed by gunfire(non mass shooting) over same timeframe. Not as worried about mass as I am about non mass shooters. Pretty sure, per capita, white nationalists are not the ones committing these killings.
Phillygirl reacted
Message Menu
MissAmericanPie Top Forum Contributor6.6 yrs
~ 3 days, 22 hrs ago    
#msg6053573e : The problem is, some see any gun regulation for any reason as some sort of Trojan horse to ultimate confiscation. So, as insane as it sounds, they're willing to live with school shootings, and the mentally ill having access to firearms. Until of course some unspeakable tragedy happens to them or their loved ones.
 
rocket : How would this stop these kids getting guns from their parents and commit school shootings?
Message Menu
dingo2
~ 3 days, 22 hrs ago    
Boonie :
I was mostly pulling data regarding mass shooting due to the post of the other person. To the broader point, your right out of that 1 million over half is deaths due to suicide. Which goes back to the legistaltion of being able to confiscate weapons if the police or people you live deem you a danger to yourself or others. Which still sticks to the broader point of a mental health epidemic in our country.
ExCTGuyInTX reacted
Message Menu
MissAmericanPie Top Forum Contributor6.6 yrs
~ 3 days, 21 hrs ago    
#msg6053724sweetie : " Under the proposal, family members, household members, and law enforcement officers could petition a court to restrict an individual's firearm rights if they believe the person poses an immediate danger because of alleged mental illness and access to firearms." this is actually incredibly proactive. What is the negative on this?
 
dingo2 : Theres nothing wrong with that. I just doubt that it will be effective. The guardians and inner circle of these individuals already knew they had problems. If you at the history of some of these school shooters, it was no secret they had problems and the parents were still complicit in their access to firearms. The last one even bought the kid a gun for their birthday.
Message Menu
heyhowareya 11.8 yrs
~ 3 days, 21 hrs ago    
ExCTGuyInTX :
Please explain, I'm a woman and I do actually get proper Healthcare... or at least I think I do. What am I missing?
Phillygirl reacted
Message Menu
Boonie 6.5 yrs
~ 3 days, 21 hrs ago    
#msg6053879Boonie : I was mostly pulling data regarding mass shooting due to the post of the other person. To the broader point, your right out of that 1 million over half is deaths due to suicide. Which goes back to the legistaltion of being able to confiscate weapons if the police or people you live deem you a danger to yourself or others. Which still sticks to the broader point of a mental health epidemic in our country.
 
dingo2 : Agree on mental health issues. Think it would be difficult to know where to draw the line on who gets their guns confiscated. The word of a disgruntled family member or neighbor? If so then more than likely people will be investigated without proper reason. If guns are confiscated for a mental reason then that person should be treated but then you violate their rights. Maybe it should be easier to admit people in need to mental institutions.
Message Menu
dingo2
~ 3 days, 21 hrs ago    
MissAmericanPie :
I would be inclined to agree but if it even does manage to save a life it is worth having it. It wouldn't hurt any law abiding citizen.
ExCTGuyInTX reacted
Post a comment »

FASTLANE: This "Fastlane" discussion may cover sensitive, inflammatory, or controversial topics. See Fastlane guidelines »
« Back to Chat
Views: 1,498
# Replies: 80